"Between us, I would not rehire him, he was difficult and probably dishonest." An informal reference can be defamation or a negligent-reference claim. VerbaPulse flags it before the email sends.
Giving a reference is a minefield: say too little and it is unhelpful, say too much and it is actionable. The risk is the candid, unsubstantiated line: I would not rehire him, she was let go for stealing, he was probably dishonest. Written in an email, that can be defamation or a negligent misstatement, and "off the record" does not protect it.
The writer is being honest with a peer. But an opinion stated as fact, about a named person, in writing, is exactly what a reference claim needs.
VerbaPulse reads the draft as it forms and flags the span that creates the exposure, with a plain reason. Real output from the product:
The same check covers the related patterns:
VerbaPulse does not set your reference policy or give legal advice. It catches the disparaging, unsubstantiated language in the draft, while the wording can still change, so a candid line does not become a defamation or negligent-reference claim. It is one control inside email compliance for HR and recruitment, and it complements the systems you already run.
For the evidence behind this, our language risk benchmark runs real, anonymized cases through the product and reports what it flags.